Rethinking Speed Cameras: A Global Perspective on Policy, Technology, and Equity

Day 2 of 30 Days, 30 Cases — Policy Meets Technology: Speed Cameras

What happens when a city installs speed cameras—and then considers removing them? Ontario’s pause on automated speed enforcement (ASE) in Vaughan shows how policy and technology intersect.

Data clearly shows speed cameras reduce speeding by around 50% and cut average speeds by nearly a quarter.

Local Success:

As per the City of Toronto's Automated Speed Enforcement Program Evaluation Report 2023, "the proportion of drivers speeding in 30, 40, and 50 km/h speed zones respectively dropped from 59.8%, 51.7%, and 58.4% pre-intervention to 43.3%, 29.2%, and 35.7% when the ASE devices were operational".

Excessive speeding (>20 km/h over) dropped ~87%
85th percentile speed fell by 6–8 km/h across most zones
Over 80% of camera locations saw lower average speeds

Global Success: UK Fixed Cameras: Speeding fell 71%, road deaths & serious injuries down ~40%

Practical Challenges:

Legal accountability: proving who was driving can sometimes be challenging
Revenue perception: some intersections generate high fines, raising “cash grab” concerns
Context matters: school zones at 2 AM being treated the same as that of 2 PM, signage issues, low-traffic areas may need adjusted enforcement

Global Best Practices:

NYC: enforces only significant violations, avoiding fines for minor infractions
Seattle: has considered offering Equity Measures discounted fines to low-income drivers to prevent disproportionate financial burdens.
UK & Europe: engage communities for transparency and trust

A Balanced Approach: Speed Enforcement works and the data shows it, however, we can optimize it to address public perception:

Time-based enforcement: limit school zone cameras to peak hours
Clear Thresholds: Speed limits that trigger enforcement to focus on significant violations
Graduated Penalties: Fines based on the severity and frequency of offenses, with considerations for the driver's ability to pay
Engage the Community: Involving local residents in the planning and evaluation of speed enforcement programs to ensure transparency and trust.

As municipalities evaluate their speed enforcement strategies, it's essential to balance technological advancements with equitable policies and community engagement. By learning from global practices and considering economic factors, systems can be developed that enhance road safety without compromising fairness.

Safety works. Let’s optimize, not eliminate.

Comments

Why I Decided To Move Halfway Across The World To Canada

"Can you go halfway around the world, and live in a cold city with freezing winters? Can you leave your friends and family? Wouldn't you be lonely?" -Jumpa Lahiri, The Namesake This is the exact question I asked myself, as I saw my invitation letter from the Government of Canada with the following words: "We are pleased to invite you to apply for permanent residence under the Federal Skilled Workers". This is a highly competitive score-based immigration system for experienced professionals valued internationally for Canada's social benefits, healthcare, education, and a high quality of life. I usually never second-guess, but in that moment, the prospect of quitting a well-paying reseach & consulting job in India and the proximity to my people to start life from square one barely held any appeal. More so, because I love India. The love, the education, the principles, the family values, the work diligence, the peace-loving outlook, the experiences, ...

Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs - In the Context of Workforce Management and Marriages

Abraham Maslow, a psychologist, created the theory of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs to assist business owners in maintaining elevated levels of employee engagement. The theory proposes that there are five essential needs that drive human motivation, arranged in a hierarchical order. Maslow's theory states that people first attend to their basic needs, then progress to higher level needs only once the lower level of needs are met, leading to a sense of fulfillment. In marketing, the hierarchy is used to market to specific groups of people based on similar needs. However, it can also be applied to other areas - to ascertain employees engagement and arguably, even in marriages! Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs in the Workplace : Many companies use this hierarchy in the workplace to determine how to motivate employees and meet their needs. 1. Physiological needs Survival needs such as coffee, clean water, comfortable working environment, breaks to eat, access to a restro...

Stereotypes Debunked

Note: Some content of this article is set up in Indian context, and might not be understood by other readers. You need to read this article because there is a very high probability that you are subconsciously driven by conventional or formulaic conceptions or images of a few things which are degrading to a group, a state or a caste. More often than not, it is not the fault of the people who stereotype and form an image of a particular thing that they don't want to change, but weakness of the society as a whole which fails to introspect, find loopholes in its judgemental capabilities and change. A very pathetic form of stereotyping is the baniya stereotyping. It's a shame that even the so called ''educated'' people in most parts of the country use 'baniya' as just another word to insult someone by meaning to call them miser or the money-minded. If you think that miserliness is quintessentially a baniya quality, you might need some help. Have you ever ...

Search This Blog

Want to look for something?